Thursday, June 14, 2007

Notun Kore Pabo Bole - Breaking Frontiers in Rabindrasangeet


It is raining…pouring in fact.

The monsoons have provided a perfect backdrop as Sahana’s voice fills up my small antechamber, and I wonder, how in the world do I
transmit this feeling of unison- with the lyrics, the raindrops and the all-pervading calm peppering her impeccable notes. Yet, I must write about this latest foray into the world of Tagore Songs, breaking the shackles of a hegemonic Vishva Bharati straitjacket. I simply have to.
The danger, needless to say, lies precisely there. There is this sheer euphoria of rediscovering the 19th century Genius in terms of today’s sound, in the realm of unchartered territories of choral harmony, electronic soundscape. And this makes it nearly impossible to objectively view the experiment. But then luckily have tasted the works of Joy Sarkar, Abraham Mazumdar, Durbadawl Chattopadhyaye and Amit Bandhopadhyaye in the domain of alternate arrangement of Tagore songs. Hence probably getting an unaffected perspective was a wee bit easier.
Talking about affectations, let’s get going with the post mortem. While Sahana’s tonal quality, the ‘jawari’ or the microtones and the presence of ‘gamagam’ or wavy resonance is enviable, her gayaki and diction is still affected by the Shantiniketanesque drawls and stretches. Something, if one doesn’t hear her speak, might put it down as a tool specially invoked for singing of Tagore songs. Hence, the criticism that she doesn’t sing in the diction she speaks in is alluring, though not quite valid as I have found out. But beyond that slight affectation, there is something very unique about her voice. There is this tinge of melancholy, which for some songs is a huge blessing, and for some, a constraint which needs conscious care. For example, when she sings ‘Ki jaani kishero laagi praano kore haaye haaye’ (Phule phule dhole dhole e) or ‘Ekla diner buker bhetore byathar toofan tole’ (Oi je jhawrer meghe)…I feel these lines were written for her voice. But then, in the same song ( Oi je jhawrer meghe), this melancholy is a constraining factor as it dampens the nervous energy which one associates with the trembling anticipation of the song. In fact, Oi je jhawrer meghe is probably one of the most intriguing renditions in the album. In places, she sounds deliciously somber and fills up the senses with a strange melancholy, probably a result of a very adolescent feel to her rendition…painting the image of a 15 year old child-woman down with fever, looking out of the window into the impending monsoon. In other places, she sounds slightly insipid and, to borrow from William Porter, paints a gray pigeon sitting on a gray roof against a gray sky- the energy of green is missing from the soundscape.
Legend and the CD inlay leaflet has it that, it is this soundscape the alchemists like Joy Sarkar, Arnob Sayon Chowdhury are after…to find the golden sepia which will elevate the compostions and lyrics of Tagore to the still unexplored land of El Dorado. And there, Arnob succeeds, and how. He goes for a mélange of synthesized instruments, flute, esraj, khol, tabla and creates magic- in all, but Etodin je boshe chhilem. Probably, there is an inherent bias in yours truly against the contrived nature of lyrics and the commonplace predictability of the composition…but somehow it seems worse than it usually sounds with the techno horsehoof beats and strings sustain. But barring that, Arnob leaves an indelible impact on the listener’s mind- be it the Himalayan majesty of the Drupadi Tomarei koriyachhi jibonero dhrubotara and its dulcet esraj prelude, or the tinkling beats of the playful Tumi kon pawthe je ele. Masterstrokes? Bringing out the distinctive beauty of the Desh raag by a beautifully woven esraj interlude in Oi je jhawrer. The thoughtful and discerning use of two stage choral harmony in Phule phule dhole or Aamaar nishitho raatero, the latter giving a distinct feel of a lonely, silent night where even heartbeats have an echo, following in loyal harmonization. Or the pearl drops as one enters ‘Hridoyegogone shawjolo ghawno nobino meghe’ and one can almost feel the pitter patter of the ‘Rawsher dhara’; in More bhabonaare ki haawaaye maataalo. More bhabonaare, which is credited to Tagore, but is actually composed by Shushil Bhanja Chowdhury, is probably the most visual of the arrangements, the pearl drops and the bass guitar collaborating to etch out a fantastic vascillation of thoughts, aided by gusts of the monsoon winds. Then there are conventional touches like the flute in Tomaar khola hawa and the tabla in More bhabonare, which to Arnob’s credit, sound amazingly fresh.
What is also fresh is Sahana’s take as a communicator in some of the songs. While she is not that effective in songs like More bhabonaare, Tomaar khola hawa (in both songs Arnob’s arrangement clearly overshadows her in efficacy) or Kon puraaton, in some songs the delivery is ethereal. Tomarei koriyachhi suits the austerity of her diction to the hilt, and her confession, her surrender is immortalized by her superbly restrained emoting. In Aaj jyotsnaraate, she makes an impact despite the precedence of a similar yet brilliantly minimalist version of the same. Joy Sarkar was the arranger in that version, and Sraboni Sen was the singer…hence establishing a separate identity for this version was not easy. But she, in collusion with Arnob did so with élan, imparting the sad, wistful tinge remarkably well. Phule phule dhole dhole was exquisite as well, not the least due to her beautifully delicate and smooth delivery. But the piece de resistance remains Aamaar nishitho raatero baadolodhara, a song which despite having a few heavyweight interpretations by reputed names, I believe Sahana has made her own. You would only notice Arnob’s ubiquitous use of bass on the third or fourth hearing, for the first two times, you will want to soak your blues in the divine grains of her voice. I tried very hard to shake off the hangover of my first exposure to Arnob-Sahana’s magic in an experimental, unpublished rebel CD, few years back during the days of the copyright. A CD which also featured other singers like Manoj and Manisha Murali Nayyar, Vikram Singh and Aditi Paul (the Indian Idol aspirant). Sahana’s only song in that collection was Aamaar nishitho raatero, and it captured my imagination like no other. Nothing has changed, I guess.
In all, Notun kore pabo bole rocks. Blues and pops, rather. And as winds of change sweeps across the vast landscape of Tagore songs and their presentation, the album goes a long way in establishing the fact, that times they are a changing. And changing for the better, if you ask our generation. Tagore himself once said, that however well-paved and rosy might be path of tradition and convention, it is only by traversing the thorn-strewn alleys of innovation and re-interpretation which can bring creative emancipation and evolution.
A number of people have started taking to those demanding streets of glory and you know what? It’s about time too….
Time to savour the rainbow of interpretations.
Because the skies have cleared now.
Because it has stopped raining…pouring, in fact.

My Hindi Male Playback Singers Playing Eleven

My playing eleven traveling to Mars for the Inter-Galactic Cup for playback singers…

Manna Dey- An opening batsman in the classical mould, who can adapt remarkably to any conditions…be it swinging taans or seaming emotions. Had trained under coach KC Right which probably accounts for the correctness of his shots. Who can forget his epic Ketaki gulab juhi innings where he encountered the bouncers from the terrifying fast bowler Josheph Bhimson with consummate ease. That smooth flowing Har taraf ab yahin afsane under the demanding pitch conditions of Madan Gardens. Or for that matter the delicate, quivering, late-cut laced innings Ae mere pyare watan when he represented Afghanistan in a voice modulation exhibition match. A batsman for all occasions really, but generally underrated and with a low profile due to lack of Actor endorsements.

Sonu Nigam- Partnering him would be the young blood recently grafted into the team after a string of solid performances in the domestic arena. Started off with idolizing the icon of Hindi Playback, Md.Rafi. Strengths…solid classical defence, ability to go over the top in the first fifteen overs for songs in the ODI s, remarkably fit with arrogant fielding capabilities. Weakness…to go over the top, playing irresponsible shots to clear that fielder at extra murki or yodel, and as a result terminating a budding innings. Has been reined in by his domestic co-player, S.E.L Lotmore, off late with surprisingly good results.

Md.Rafi- Has served HFM for years (though the last years before retirement, depended on a lot on the past laurels for the National Selection) and is undoubtedly one of the main pillars of the team. A legend, a remarkably humble genius…when he bends his voice, and then his vocal chords caress the notes through the covers like an affectionate knife through butter, the result is a sheer treat for the audience. Has the full repertoire of shots, though looks a bit ungainly when tries the unconventional madcap paddle.. patented by a different member of the team. Looks the best when playing in tandem with Sachin in the domestic circuit, for he brings out the best in him. Their most famous partnerships include the Hum bekhudi mein against the Andaman XI, a long standing and playing HMV record. Similarly, Polygram record for the last wicket in the 1970's, Mera Man Tera Pyasaa in the evergreen Navketan grounds. But when partnering someone like Laxmi Ratan Dholak-laa, looks bored. Again has a solid defence set in the classical mould, where he actually smells even the half-notes when in a forward defensive posture. An ideal one-down candidate.

Kishore Kumar- The most enigmatic member of the team and a very media-shy person who hates post-match conferences. An all-rounder in the truest sense of the word, has a more than useful composing arm which can bowl you over with disarmingly simple deliveries. But it is his batting which is the main crowd puller. Very unorthodox style, but superbly effective mostly. Is a complete natural, has an utter disregard for coaching book manuals and depends on his ear-voice co-ordination for last minute improvisations. And he has god-gifted timing as well…when the ball of emotions hits his timbre, the wooden sound is one of the sweetest around. He is famous for his reverse sweep yodels amongst other unconventional shots- one of the finest innings of his in this regard is the one which he played for his home production county in the treacherous Jhumroo Talaiyya grounds. His coming of age innings came in the 1969 World Cup, where he pulverized the opposition with a triple hundred partnering an indisposed Sachin with Rahul as a runner. Along with Md.Rafi, the fulcrum of the batting order- when they hit them, they stay box-office hit.

Shankar Mahadevan- Again a new entry to the team, with a reputation of picking up runs at a frantic pace with impeccable shot selection. Also has represented the planet in Inter-Galactic tournaments for Fusion and Carnatic musicians. Though an all-rounder with brisk discotheque pace mixed with sentimental slower ones, he can make the cut solely as a batsman. Holds the HMV record (though for a non-film club match) for the fastest innings Breathless, where he scored about three stanzas in one delivery (The record was challenged later, though!). An utility member of the team, with a small but impressive history of good performances against classical pace, contemporary leg-spin of dance numbers and dibbly dobbly medium rhythm of love songs. Memorable performances include Jaane yeh kya ho gaya against Armaanian National Team and Aasmaan ke paar shayad while playing for Rockford county with S.E.L Lotmore.

Amit Kumar- Completing the list of batsmen, would be the mercurial talent of this member whose robust hitting have left many a ears craving for more. Being short on technique, he makes it up with his lazy elegance and powerful baritone of the bat. Had a very bright start to his career under the captaincy of and in partnership with Rahul, but lost the plot somewhere due to an inexplicable indifference. The grapevine has it that it was due to explicable differences with the Board, but whatever it may be, a definite selection for my team. One of his earliest innings, Bade achche lagte hai, in an partnership with Rahul again, is etched out in public memory..though my personal favourite remains the tremendous Daur-e-khiza where he stitched a remarkable partnership batting with Kishore Kumar. Does have the penchant for unconventional shot selection, and probably the only one in the team who can hold a teeny-weeny candle to Kishore Kumar in that regard.

Hemant Kumar- Though he was first selected as a composing wicketkeeper-singing batsman, somehow he is more well-known for his batsmanship. But in reality he is a very limited batsman with just one god-gifted aspect- the sound of his timbre, or in other words, his timing. In fact, the famous words of S.O'Leal, if God were to time his strokes, he would do it like Hemant. Would, on many occasions, wrongly accentuate his footwork, but would still get away due to this divine timing. On the other what is hardly given its true recognition is his composure, while wicketkeeping. His is a simple, uncluttered approach to the orchestration of his movements behind the stumps. Something so fluid, so dulcet….that when in his movement behind the stump, he would be poetry in motion. Such is his charm, that when he would sledge Zaraa nazron se kehdo ji, nishana chuk naa jaaye and the batsman would inevitably miss the line of the ball and get stumped, the batsman would turn around and say "Play it again, Hem".

Talat Mehmood- A medium fast bowler whose run-up is as smooth as a dewdrops sliding off palm leaves in the early morning hours. Effortless approach to the singing crease, and not a single crease in his action which lets go of the note in a sublime delicacy of movement. A famous ghazaler of beer, a down to earth hardworking member of the team, he is an invaluable asset. And unlike some tearaway bowlers like Sajjad Whosane and Anon Malik who have had short stays in public memories due to injuries, absolutely non-existent attitude or verbal duals. Most of his great performances have come in the Yusufkhana grounds, his favourite stadium and his best bowling performance personally has been the one in response to his pain at the match-fixing allegations leveled against the team…Sham-e-gham ki qasam…

Mukesh- Slow Right Nose bowler, had strangely laboured and technically faulty action. With great mass appeal because his honest approach to the game, believes in the old school of thought which resulted slow, sad, flighted deliveries, which would probably take so much time to reach the batsman, he would get frustrated. But his talent lies in the fact that after five pedestrian deliveries would impart a deadly one and would hit right at the middle stump of the heart. A very deceptive customer who can bowl a very ordinary delivery, which will grow on you, and you will be taken by surprise by the extra bounce. Case in point, that remarkable over that he bowled in Khai-i-aam (renamed as Asharjah in 1981) in UAE…a googly in Woh subah kabhi to, a venomous snorter in Chinoo arab humara and the faster one in Aasmaan pe hain khuda…was promoted up the order to two down for nasal pinch hitting under S.O'Leal's captaincy for the Anand Cup and did a decent job. However Manna Dey admitted in a post-match conference that he thought the match situation demanded Kishore Kumar's exuberance which could have sealed the issue faster.

Yesudas- A legend in the local circuit, probably his heavily accentuated south-on action cut short his career, But probably one of greatest who have taken to the red cherry, and wielded it with supreme control and undisputed mastery, especially when it came to classical swing bowling. Impeccable line and length of rendition, his famous exploits include ripping through the opponent with a breezy Jaaneman jaaneman in Chateau S' Batelet in France and the Chand akela/Koi gaataa main so jaataa with opening fast bowler J.Dev. An automatic choice.

Hariharan- Has the variety in the ouvre to bamboozle any batsman. Be it Yo-yorkers or Bandish-bouncers, Love song late swings or Depressing doosras, he has delivered them all. The television graphics crew does have a problem when he swings (and seams and spins) into action. Again with a plethora of remarkable achievements to boot in the local circuit, his foray into HFM arena has been especially fruitful with the partnerships forged with opening bowler AR Rayman, the pioneer of electronic bowling shoes. Both, aided by technology, have bowled spells of great character and melodic content. His excellent performances include the match saving Sun ri sakhi, the Chanda re (on not exactly a flat pitch though) spell and Nahin saamne in a friendly at Naini-Taal. Will share the new ball with Yesudas, with an alaap.

P.S. The reserve bench would have Suresh Wadkar, Bhupinder and Sukhwinder Singh. So martians, here we come....

An Ode To the Timeless One (Published in The Hindustan Times, 4th January, 2006, co-authored by Anirudhdha Bhattacharjee)

All characters and incidents in the following article are real. Any resemblance with any imaginary person or incident is purely co-incidental.
These lines are a part of a crucial disclaimer which should dissuade the readers from construing this piece as an abstract from a Greek Tragedy. But be warned, even in this case, Fate treats the Hero in the most ironical of manners. He is betrayed by the benefactors of his deeds in the cold logic of commercial viability, he is wrapped in solitude till the very end, fame and success are mischievous class mates in an eternal game of hide and seek, and he departs for Olympus with one last flourishing bang. We speak ofRahul Dev Burman…..the one composer in Hindi Filmdom who truly transcends time and musical taste.
We are not exactly sticklers for tributes, for Death often is the missing masterpiece which has uplifted many an under-achiever and also-ran to reasonably legendary proportions in the world of Hindi films. But the sheer range and pedigree of tributes which has swelled in favour of Burman Jr. demand serious introspection. When on one hand giants like Pt. Shiv Kumar Sharma, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan and Pt. IIlayaraja swears by his genius, senior colleagues in the stature of Salil Chowdhury hailed him as the ‘The only true musical phenomenon in the last twenty years’. While Manna Dey and Majrooh Sultanpuri, who put together, have worked with almost the entire Who’s Who legion ofthe musical fraternity, certify his supremacy, every discotheque or pub resonates with his creations still today. Even the modern music makers like Jatin-Lalit, Anu Malik, AR Rehman or Pritam never fall short of naming him, even when pushed to the situation where they can take only one name. Is there a key to the secret of RD’s longevity, reach and timelessness as a music composer?
There are some answers which have been generalised over the years. That he could get into the exact mood or situation, that he poured every drop of his inspiration and creative energy into planning the movement of the song, that he knew how to best use the voices of Kishore and Asha, that he knew when exactly he neededthe little extra from Lata or Manna Dey….so on and so forth. But most significantly, RD felt the pulse of the era. The early seventies were politically troubled times. Hippie Cult, Flower Power, Naxalite, Leftistetc. were buzz words in college and university canteens. The taboo associated which these elements were being rubbed off at a breathtaking speed. RD, himself a rebel, infused the rebellious elements in his creations. In a sense, he wanted to break away from the shackles of bondage which had made Indian film music a monotonous, predictable affair, more often than not; where a sitar or a veena replicatedthe basic tune, a surfeit of violins played the raga movement on which the song was based, the tablas and the dholaks played the normal 2-4 / 3-6 beat, where the beat pattern of the ‘mukhda’ was religiously replicated in the antara. And this insight, something on the lines of how Salil Chowdhury interpreted the genesis of a new musical package, was his most coveted secret in the string of success he had in that period. His works in a lot of way were Anti-Establishment in the realm of Hindi Filmdom. To begin with, he broke the norms of conventional rhythm. He brought in exotic beat patterns like Bossanova through Maar daalega dard-e-Jigar ( Pati Patni) . He could compose an exceedingly soulful number like‘Kya Janoon sajan’ (Lata in Baharon ke Sapne) and maintain the rhythm via the electric guitar, using the leather sparingly in the form of a congo and not the tabla as practised over the years by traditionalists, way back in 1966. He utilized the Madal tarang to devastating effect in songs like Tere bina jiya jaayenaa (Ghar) or Mehbooba Mehbooda (Sholay) . Then, he moved away from the usual cluttering of huge orchestral arrangement of industry bigwigs. When a whole lot of upcoming composers were keen to emulate the number of musicians used by Naushad or Shankar - Jaikishan, RD was riveted to the staid, modest rule passed on by his father who insisted that the number of instruments should never outweigh the singer's voice(‘Lota gayegi aaur ek instrument baajega’ remains the Senior Burman’s one of the most well-known remarks). Thus, even his loudest and fastest songs (for eg:Maine dekha ek sapna (Samadhi) / Yahan nahin kahungi(Mr Romeo) ) were arranged in an uncluttered manner to impart an unhurried feel.
The cynics might ask that this rebel in the man might have won him favours in that era, but how did his music transcend time? That answer lies in the sheer completeness of his music- RD brought to our film music a fresh look, an unsullied vitality, as a composer who was at ease at handling Western harmony,Indian melody, Ethnic flavour, Latin rhythm and recording technology. His thorough knowledge of both Indian classical music and Western chord system also came in handy in composing songs that were a mix of multiple ragas and chords. Pandit Ajoy Chakrabarty, once demonstrated the use of multiple ragas, Khamaj &Kalavati, in the song ‘Kuch to log kahenge’(AmarPrem). Paradoxically, an arranger can clearly identify that the progression is definitely chord based! Pacham digged the concept of jamming, a term of common usage in Western music, and many of the tune and rhythm forms were the result of his jamming sessions. But in carving out the final output, he kept his own counsel and ultimately, like his father again, followed his own hunches and judgements. There was this new sound which he gifted Hindi Filmdom, by using new and under utilized musical instruments and derivatives like the Saxophone, Synthesizer, Drums and Flanger, new recording technology, beat forms, creation of special instruments to convey a specific effect in mind, capture natural sounds and in fact, coercing music out of unsuspecting objects of daily use. Who can forget the memorable banshee wails created specially by an instrument developed by RD for Gabbar’s signature tune in Sholay or the innocuous reso-reso doing the honours in ‘Sach mere yaar hai’(Saagar) and ‘Mere saamnewali khidki mein’ (Padosan)? Or for that matter the empty desks doubling up for percussion in ‘Master ji ki aa gayi chiththi’ from Kitaab? Another remarkable facet of RD Burman’s compositions is that despite having a explicitly existing signature style, his music was deliciously unpredictable. His style of composing was such that one minor note, one truant beat could lift the song to unexpected heights.The last line of the mukhda in Rut hain milan ki(Mela) or Bemausam bahar ke (Bundlebaaz), both otherwise predictably patterned Dholak augmented love songs are cases in point. Or probably the back vocals in Bindiya tarse (Phir Wahi Raat) merging with the main melody like a twinkling stream joining a garrulous river. Or the notational volte face, the twist in progression in the antara of Sun Nita (Dil Diwana) which would make Agatha Christie proud. In fact so all-encompassing was his music making style, so sweeping was his knowledge that he could actually create music in style of other music directors, and sometimes beat them at their own game. The use of dholaks in Kahe ko bulaya (Humshakal) or Sawan ka mahina (Nehle Pe Dehla) can be pitted against any similar treatment by LP. SD Burman’s effortless soulfulness can be traced in Khuli khuli zulphen(Parchhaiyan) or Bada natkhat hai (Amar prem), as can the melodic pyrotechniques of Salilda in Diwana karke(Mere Jeevan Saathi). In fact, HMV, had indeed by mistake, included the Bengali version of the song in a Salil Chowdhury-Lata compilation. Whether be it the classically moulded ‘a la Naushad or Vasant Desai’ song (Humen tumse pyar kitna (Kudrat), Gori teri paijaniya (Mehbooba), Roz roz dali (Angoor), Piya bawri (Khubsoorat), Kajra badarva (Pati Patni), Beeti naa bitai (Parichay), Aao kahan se (Budhdha Mil Gaya) or Bheeni bheeni bhor (Dil padosi hai), or the BappiLahiri-esque dance tracks with synthetic and psychedelic sounds; he was equally at ease.
Like any successful artist, he too was heavily influenced by works of other masters, but in retrospect was labelled a plagiarist by the media. It is another matter that he could keep his unique stamp of authority over the numbers he re-created. Today, most of the originals may have been wiped off from memory, but most of the inspired numbers remain. His inspiration was not the commonly understood syndrome,‘copying the tune’, but extended to incorporation of different forms of tunes and rhythm patterns into his music. This stemmed mainly from his deep knowledge of jazz, Latin American music and Broadway /Off-Broadway musicals. And the way he metamorphosed the original was nothing short of a miracle. Otherwise how can one explain a non-descript musical interlude from Procul Harem’s ‘Whiter Shade of Pale’ turning into one of the poignantly crafted love songs in HindiFilms (Tum ho mere dil ki dhadkan from Manzil)?
But his musical genius notwithstanding, RD Burman was pathetic at promotion. He had no bona fide muscle in the hedonistic Bombay film circle to even voice his opinion, let alone bloat it. At times it appeared that he was the staple punching bag of the media. And his consistent failure at being at the right place at the right time with the right people resulted in him losing many a prestigious project. RD was more of aninarticulate dipsomaniac whose world was confined to his music and his close circuit of friends. But even,those friends, barring few, hardly lived up to their billing. Bigwigs like Ramesh Sippy and Shekhar Kapur dropped him for no tangible reason even after he had given both commercially hit and timeless music for their films. Manmohan Desai, having used RD for AaGale Lag Jaa and Rampur ka Lakshman, his best musicals by miles, never said a word in RD’s favour in the future. He opted for temporal chart toppers and mediocrity, as the music of his films were literally gone in sixty seconds under the onslaught of time. But the unkindest cut of all came when Shubhash Ghai promised him Ram Lakhan, a big banner film which could have revived his creative avalanche, and then later switched to LP, another close associate of his. And while all this happened, RD could only look on from his Juhu verandah, behind the dhoti he had put up to prevent anyone from seeing the ‘great’ RD unemployed. Talk about Greek Tragedies and how!!!
RD Burman is a brand today. Music companies recover their cost in a twinkling when they repackage his music which he non-strategically gifted to turkeys like Chor Police, Adhura Aadmi, Sitamgar, Garam Masala, Mardonwali Baat and Namumkin. From sophomores to old hats, everyone reveres him to the extent of divinity. Only if this appreciation was devoid of the Van Goghian lag, he wouldn’t have died a lonely death. Only if there were people who would give him a chance to challenge new frontiers in composing, we could have had another Amar Prem or Hum Kisise Kum Naheen or Ishq Ishq Ishq. Only if Fate (of the Greek Tragedy variety) hadn’t proved his dazzling comeback to be his swansong...Only if……

Celebrating Brahma (Published in The Telegraph, 26th August; with trivia inputs from Anirudhdha Bhattacharjee)

If the 70s in Hindi film music was to be mapped, there is no iota of doubt about who the Holy Troika would be.
The musical team of Laxmikant-Pyarelal would be Vishnu, hugely popular with an enviable appeal that would reach the commonest of Puja rooms. LP battled and duped the demons of Box-Office Failure with Vishnu-like cerebral use of power; choosing the right banner and rationing their talent.
Blissfully unaware of most worldly matters and lost in the marijuana of music would be R.D. Burman or Shiva: destroying all established notions of rhythm and arrangement in HFM and dancing his Tandav to the tune of true World Music within the paradigm of Bollywood.
But moving away from these charismatic gods and the bloodless wars between Shaivites and Vaishnavis, our cynosure is the third of the trinity. Like Brahma, who has only a sole temple after him, even at the peak of their powers in the 70s, the Kalyanji-Anandji duo always remained in the shadow of the two giants. KA’s contribution is scarcely the stuff drawing room uproar or tumultuous exchanges on e-forums are made of; it is hardly evaluated with the same intensity. But, almost quietly, they continued to rub shoulders with the big names for two decades or more, with fervour and tenacity.
Kalyanji Veerji Shah, the life and soul of the duo, was the son of a prospective grocer who took interest in musical instruments from a very early age. At an age when a child learning an instrument is wowed at, he developed a musical instrument called the Pattar Tarang! His innovative streak continued as, after being incorporated in SJ’s orchestra, with Hemant Kumar, he ushered in HFM’s first electronic sound through the German instrument claviolin. Remember the haunting snake-charmer’s been theme from Hemant Kumar’s immortal score in Nagin? Yes, that was Kalyanji himself creating magic. And with these musical escapades he finally caught the attention of Subhash Desai in 1958, and was offered his first independent assignment ? Samrat Chandragupta. This was followed up by Post Box 999, which among other creations had the Hemant-Lata dulcet declaration of insomnia ? , neend na mujh ko aaye. With his third film, Satta Bazaar, younger brother Anandji joined him and the rest, as they say, is history.
The early 60s were difficult, but KA scraped through given the support of producers and directors like Baburao Mistry, Subhash Desai, Ravindra Dave, Pramod Chakravarty and Suraj Prakash who couldn’t afford topnotch composers. But come 1965, and all that changed. Four of their five films, Himalay Ki God Mein, Jab Jab Phool Khile, Purnima and Saheli made it to the top of the charts. In JJPK, they moved away from Kalyanji’s earlier use of heavy orchestra in the SJ or Naushad mould, with startling results. In fact, the year’s success landed them with a couple of prestigious projects like Saraswatichandra and Upkar. While the former had among its National-Award winning score, the hugely popular love ditty in Raag Yaman, Chandan-sa badan; the latter had the ethereal Kasme vaade pyaar wafa sab which became the rage of the nation.
By this time, KA had developed their late 60s- early 70’s style, which was quintessentially an extension of the Bengal School of composing heralded by SD and Hemant Kumar. This mandated the use of limited Shudhdha notes, sporadically interspersed with Komal or Teevra notes, all stressed upon for a lasting impact. In the mellifluous Kishore-Asha duet Aankhon aankhon mein from Mahal (1969), the mukhda is an exposition of this skill, where only the first three notes of any form of music (Sa, Re and Ga) have been woven into the fabric with mind-boggling results. In fact, the same note progression often formed their signature tune and was recast intelligently in fractionally different moulds to create classics like Zindagi ka safar (Safar, 1970), Dil to hai dil (Muqaddar Ka Sikander, 1978) or Mera jeevan kora kagaaz (Kora Kagaz, 1974).
The period 1970-73 found KA at their commercial and creative zenith. The roll of honour included films like Safar, Blackmail, Johny Mera Naam, Purab Aur Paschim, Geet, Ghar Ghar Ki Kahani, Kathputli, Chhoti Bahu, Mere Humsafar, Samjhauta and Victoria No. 203. A very successful relationship was forged in 1973 when they proved to be the mascot for a lanky newcomer from Allahabad who redefined anger on celluloid. Numerous stage shows and hugely successful shows at that, were a direct and important byproduct of this association. However, as years went by, by the late 70s-early 80s, quality began to watch from the wings as the appeasement of the galleries took centerstage. And the trough crept up faster than the crest had arrived.
Viju Shah, one of Kalyanji’s five offspring, tried to give the last shot in the arm with Tridev (1989), but the success was fleeting. The man who brought electronic orchestra to Hindi Film Music, eventually lost out when technology became the heart and soul of the recording rooms. And when Anandji was quizzed on AIR FM, Kolkata, about his favourite Kalyanji creation, on August 22, 2000 little did he know that it would be prophetic.
'Hum chhod chale hain mehfil ko/Yaad aaye kabhi to mat rona..'
Within 48 hours, Kalyanji had passed into posterity.

The Unsung Kishore (Published in The Telegraph, 5th August, 2005)


Come August 4th every year, Kishore Kumar aficionados will indulge in discussing myriad aspects of the maverick who dabbled in most crafts of Hindi Films, but above all was the supreme playback. And songs which are likely to be invoked will be amongst the gems he has bequeathed for billions.

For eliciting melancholy, strains of ‘Chingari koi bhadke’ or ‘Kiska rasta dekhe’…the euphoria of frolic in ‘Main hoon jhumroo’ or ‘Ina mina dika’…the superlatively philosophical in ‘Zindagi ka safar’ or ‘Kuchh to log kahenge’. But search the hinges of the treasure chest, the inner lining of the box covered with the velvet timbre of his voice and one will find a glistening diamond here, a bloodshot ruby there; songs, which courtesy the music companies or the still born films to which they belong, never drifted in to plebian hearts and ears through records, tapes or CDs. The unreleased or not properly released gems of Kishore Kumar, on their own, can give a lot of his more popular numbers a run for their money.

Though handpicking unreleased beauties should have been relatively easy, reality throws up a different picture. And the three songs which come up after a lot of indecision probably vindicate our faith in the Underdog, the Unsung. The first of these also comes with an element of very pleasant, almost divine, surprise. For those who have savoured RD Burman-Asha Bhonsle’s Bengali Puja numbers, the popular ‘Phule gondho nei (1973)’might ring more than a musical bell; it might uncork the sparkle of the nostalgia of their respective decades. This, only till one chances upon the Hindi version of this song ‘Phulon ki zubaan khubsurat ho gayi’ from an untitled production of debatable lineage. The Bengali original is an Asha solo, but here Kishore Kumar joins to take it to hitherto unchartered heights of ecstasy. The song is better arranged, the lyrics are improved upon (the Achilles Heel of Bengali Puja Numbers from RD’s stable), the emoting is optimum- but if not for anything else the song stands out for the incredible entry which Kishore effects with his resonent baritone proclaiming ‘Aakaash koraa hai,aur chand kanwaaraa hai’. Though he goes on to play ideal foil to Asha’s delicious rendition, it surely has to be one of the greatest openings in a Hindi Film Song…unexpected, stunning, regal.

The second in the collection could contend to be the ultimate song in the minimalist tradition of composing. Very little accompaniment, a hint at slight percussions, more like muted heart beats of the song. And truly, ‘Akela hoon main is jaahaan mein..’lives; Kishore Kumar’s virgin voice from the late fifties takes care of that. Inspired by the theme of ‘River of no return’ and written and composed by himself for the unreleased “Neela Aasmaan”(1960), the song had been released around a decade ago in a double cassette by Amit Kumar without finding many takers then. Kishore delivers this song so lucidly that the listener is left almost breathless. One can actually hear him pour out the solitude from the deepest recesses of his heart through the conduit of the refrain…O sticklers for the grandeur of simplicity, a must!

Finally, the third song - probably the brightest jewel of them all. Based on Raga Puriya Dhaneshree, Kishore composed this ghazal in D major scale, using chords in characteristic Kishoresque manner, defying the established norms of chord progression in the particular scale. And all this, in a matter of ten minutes while recording for the theme song of the film Pyar Ajnabi Hai (1980)- another shelved production starring himself and Leena. Much like isolated chapters of a rare manuscript, the song currently exists in two separate clippings of about 50 seconds each. But be warned - don’t hastily conclude anything about the impact of the song from its duration.50 seconds is a significant amount of time. Someone atop the WTC was planning an exotic weekend 50 seconds before the plane intervened. The baker at Pompeii was happily contemplating the shade of the loaf 50 seconds before Vesuvius burst open. In 50 seconds the hummingbird flaps its wings 3900 times and showcases the wonder of Nature. In 50 seconds, Sun’s rays cover 1/10th of their expedition to Earth in order to support photosynthesis or an even coat of tan.

For 50 seconds Junoon-e-ishq captures each and every spark of emotion created when the arrogance of persuasive love takes on the wall of stoicism.

As Potter mania grips the world, can’t help but listen in awe to this one true alumnus of Hogwarts School of Wizardry from Hindi Filmdom!!

Escaping the Pujas

The feeling closed in on me with unerring single-mindedness. I increased the volume of my music system, took refuge in a pen & paper, moved from standard to Patiala measure…but it was a losing battle….When I moved from city-ex to city-why, career was the driving force. And sure enough, I love money. But like again, during so many moments, the aftermath of my decision stands before me and quizzes me on my preference map. Friends, house of memories, at least one face, one known touch- or a rung more on the professional ladder? Do I say, the time stood still then, or do I say it was stagnant?

I am sure I could have escaped this deluge of uncomfortable queries- if it wasn’t for the time of the year. Strange- for the harder I try to severe the umbilical chord with Kolkata, it re-surfaces in some way or the other. E-mail forwards with stills from the latest creation from the potters of Kumartuli puncture my defense. Vir Sanghvi writes with élan what Pujas mean to Bengalis. The skies of Bangalore take on the ‘Sharat’ hue…the indigenous season. Even the sound of ‘ Dhaak’, the vengeful beats leak through the armour of an alien city. Broken images of my city roads, disparate smell of bastard noodles mixed with gleaming beads of sweat on enthusiastic pandal-hoppers , the quiet rustle of new leather on new feet- all prey on, feast on my solitude like ruthless vultures faced with an overgrown wildebeest.

Mauled, homesick, I reach for consolations. Words like pragmatism, professional, stoicism, grown-up, mature are propped up cushions for my aching mind- the walls of my yellow room affectionately ruffles my hair, the floor beckons me to its soft lap. The crystal glass tenderly caresses my lips, AR Rehman medicates my wounds with his latest offering- but as I said before it is a losing battle. In which one is reduced to mendicancy…begging for refuge from city-ex, begging for company from city-why, begging for a uni-dimensional preference schedule from providence, begging for either plain genius or plain mediocrity from life….O yes, I hate the Pujas. Or love it beyond reason.

A Weekend With The Shahs (July, 2004)

It was a chance comment that triggered off the blast, some casual remark about a play being staged over the weekend. Recovering from Friday night excesses, a more detailed investigation revealed that it was only half true….Naseeruddin Shah’s theatre group Motley was actually staging two plays back-to-back over the weekend! Since Ismat Aaapaa Ke Naam was first staged, I wanted to watch it but somehow like the other favourite play of mine, Winkle Twinkle, it suspiciously avoided me across cities like plague. On the top of that, there was this bonus in form of Dear Liar, a play written by Jerome Kilty in 1957 based on the correspondence between George Bernard Shaw and Stella Campbell, a famous contemporary actress. So happily my eyes went about probing the venue and the tickets and all that jazz….when the ticket prices hit me like a malignant eye-sore.
The reaction to a price in terms of demand, as classically defined, is a function of the utility, or rather the marginal utility of the good or service to the consumer. In case of theatre ticket prices, I think history also counts…maybe whether his city has an Academy of Fine Arts or not. Coming from Kolkata, where the Arts are highly subsidized, spending Rs.500 on a ticket seemed slightly weird, but Naseeruddin Shah, Ratna Pathak Shah, Ismat Khanum Chughtai and George Bernard Shaw being who they are, I really had no option. More deserving connoisseurs of the theatre were however left behind though by this prohibitive pricing, and justice favoured the corporate.
And surely enough the Saturday arrived with khadi clad intellectuals, nattily dressed crème de la crème of Delhi and chattering youngsters. There were women who seemed to be coming from the wrong side of the green room, and women who were beautifully intelligent…the men were mostly extremes- paunchy or chiseled. The anticipation was building up like a gas bubble, and I kept on consoling it with nicotine till the second bell rang. And the din quietened. Two figures confidently strutted into the spotlight, introduced themselves as Naseeruddin and Ratna Paathak Shah and took us all to the late nineteenth, early twentieth century.
The Shahs were deliciously British and as they read out the letters, or rather lived out the letters, one could almost feel the intense love and friendship, which bound Shaw and Campbell together. Despite being respectively married, pun intended, it seemed that theirs was a relationship which resembled a harp. There were strings with different intonations, different shades, and different notes- but when played by Shaw’s sharp wit or Campbell’s affectionate arrogance, sounded so beautifully harmonious, so sonorous. The World Wars, Pygmalion, St.Joan and The Great Depression haunted the slightly disappointing props like spirits as the Shahs forged and etched an unforgettable relationship under grease paint, time turning and impressing minds such as mine.
Come Sunday, I was even more excited as the period in which Ismat Aaapaa, as she was affectionately called, wrote, were the Pre-independence years which has cradled some wonderful story-tellers and ditties. Also I strongly feel as simple narrators or story-tellers, women are slightly ahead of their male counterparts…starting from our grannies. And since Motley decided to go in for the narrative style of drama, as opposed to the recreational style, it suited my expectations fine. Three of Ismat Aapaa’s short stories were told with great vigour (accompanied by a relatively pedestrian score by Vishaal Bharadwaj); they came to life as each member of Motley, the Shahs and their daughter Heeba played the Sutradhar and all the characters in each of the three plays. It started with Chui Mui enacted by Heeba who was promising and excellent in patches- the overtly strong Urdu flavour robbed her rendition of some easy flowing humour but her histrionic powers shone through all right. It was a touching tale of childbirth on a train- how a rural woman orchestrates her own delivery and how three upper class women react to the incident, interspersed with an acerbic commentary of status of women in a pre-partition Muslin household in Uttar Pradesh.
Ratna Paathak Shah was in her elements in the next story, which dealt with a love story of epic proportions, in terms of the sheer span of the passion and fecund imagery of the much-touted male ego. ‘Mughal Bachcha’ was all about the anachronism of the Mughal pride in a fast changing world under the British Rule and on a more universal note, the futility of false pride in matters of the heart. Having seen so many Gori Bis and Kaale Mians in my short tenure on this planet, identification and appreciation came very smoothly for me. Mrs. Shah’s body language was the highlight of the story as she recreated the images of the septuagenarian story-teller, of the shy yet angry, eternally optimistic Gori Bi and the haughty Kaale Mian; with consummate ease.
But as if to celebrate the saying ‘Save the best for the last’, the play beautifully climaxed to Naseer’s turn at narrating ‘Gharwali’. This story is admittedly much more malleable to dramatic adaptation and has been indeed adapted a number of times before. However Naseeruddin Shah delivered a one-man powerhouse performance to lift it to newer heights, and tempted me to change the title of this piece to An Evening With Naseeruddin Shah. Luckily for the sake of neutrality, which some wise crack had wisecracked is the greatest prejudice, I retained the original title. Otherwise his impact could might have had its sway.
‘Gharwali’ is the story of a bastard child Laajo and how society instills in her a mix of feminine servility and promiscuity, and she is as Aaapaa puts it, generous with her love, service, body and soul. Her masters change but not her willingness to serve one with virgin honesty of heart. And then she falls for Mirza, or rather the respect he gives her, the dignity, the warm security of a home that she could possess. She even gives up her promiscuous ways, only retaining her boisterous and flirtatious demeanor. It is a story of Mirza who inspite visiting brothels, strongly believes in a righteous distinction between the Andar- mahal and the outside world. How in turn, Laajo becomes his servant, then wife and then again servant is the skeleton of the narrative in form of a satire on the institution of marriage. Their relationship blooms under the master-servant paradigm..it is infact, closest to known data points of marital bliss. Only when expectations creep in with patriarchal dos and don’t with a formal marriage that the relationship sours. Mirza effectively kills off the spirit that made her irresistible to him and in the process, gets frustrated himself with the change. Only when he luckily finds out that their marriage stands annulled because she is a bastard, that he, and subsequently, they find peace. The lanterns in his Haveli are again lit up, ‘phulka’s pampered by her soft, white hands again remind him of his mother’s culinary touch and all is hunky dory. The only difference now, as the closing lines suggest, was that he doesn’t have to hesitate to jump into bed with her as before in their first master-servant tryst…technically his servant, Mirza eventually realizes that Laajo was more of a ‘Gharwali’ than the holy Nikah could ever imagine.
There are actors who make the characters they play turn into them. An art, to be fair to the mega stars of Indian acting fraternities, is not very easy and indeed indispensable for the star system to flourish and rake in the moolah. But what is really difficult is to become the character, to get under the skin. And the Shahs, did just that over this weekend, and more. For it wasn’t one skin or one heart or one mind they had to get into, it was a multitude of them, making their surname worthwhile....truly, a royal treat.